Social Media: The Cause or a Symptom of Teen Anxiety?

There were days Maddie loved social media, but many days, it weighed on her heavily, especially if she didn’t get the response to a post she had expected. Screams of “Like my post, Daddy!” would echo from her bedroom. Her moods spiked or crashed depending upon her post’s success.

The argument for a phone starts early. Unfortunately, many parents look at getting phone and it’s capabilities are inextricably connected. They aren’t. Not with companies like Gabb. Gabb devices offer the world's safest smartphones and smartwatches for kids and teens. Unfortunately, it’s only available in the US. Nate Randle, any plans to expand to Canada or beyond?

Parenting and social media are a tricky road to navigate, especially if it’s a split household. Different households have different rules, regardless of how amicable the divorce has been. The “need” for a phone within a split family is even greater because of the safety and accessibility factors. In our case, the divorce was anything but amicable. Multiple time zone differences were involved, and accessibility for divorced parents is essential, or that’s the story we tell ourselves.

By making such demands, are we prioritizing our needs ahead of our children’s? I believe it does!

When it comes to the mental health crisis among teens, social media often takes the blame. TikTok, Instagram, and Snapchat are the villains in a narrative we’ve grown comfortable with. But is it really that simple? Are these platforms truly the root cause, or are they just amplifiers of deeper issues we’ve yet to address?

Blaming social media feels satisfying. It’s tangible, visible, and everywhere. But it’s like blaming a dating app for not finding the love of your life. Sure, the app plays a role, but it’s not responsible for your readiness or the depth of your connections. Similarly, social media isn’t creating these struggles out of nowhere; it’s exposing and sometimes exacerbating the pressures teens already face.

The Double-Edged Sword of Social Media

Yes, social media has its harms. It amplifies insecurities, fosters relentless comparisons, and creates spaces where bullying thrives. Teens scroll through curated highlight reels, comparing themselves to filtered perfection and wondering why their lives fall short.

How is it that some teens can have 1,000 followers and yet feel like they have no friends? Because likes aren’t the same as love, followers aren’t the same as friends, and validation online rarely fills the void of real connection.

But for some teens, these platforms are lifelines. They find community, explore their identities, and access mental health resources. Social media is both a tool and a mirror, reflecting the environments we’ve created for our kids.

So, the question isn’t just about screen time or algorithms; it’s why teens are so vulnerable to social media's negative effects.

The Pressure Cooker of Modern Life

The root issues run deeper than the apps on their phones. Our schools, meant to be safe spaces for growth, have turned into pressure cookers. Teens face relentless academic stress, overloaded schedules, and the constant push for perfection.

Maddie once told me, “I feel like I’m in a race I never signed up for.” She was trying hard to meet expectations, fit in, and find her place in a system that often felt impossible to navigate.

We’ve normalized the 80-hour week for teens, where classes, extracurriculars, and social pressures leave little room for self-care or reflection. Add to that a mental health system that offers token gestures, like an awareness assembly here and a hotline poster there, and it’s no wonder teens feel overwhelmed.

Parenting in a Productivity-Obsessed World

As parents, we’re part of this system, too. We’re told to raise “successful” kids, but success is often defined by grades, scholarships, and trophies, not by emotional resilience or happiness. What is the real goal here?

In trying to protect our kids and set them up for the future, are we unintentionally adding to their stress? Are we modelling balance, or are we modelling burnout?

These aren’t easy questions to ask, but they’re necessary. Maddie’s journey forced me to examine not only the pressures she faced but also the expectations I had unintentionally contributed to.

So, Where Do We Go From Here?

This isn’t about blaming parents, schools, or even social media. It’s about understanding the bigger picture. Social media might play a role, but it’s not the whole story. If we want to help teens, we need to address the environments they’re growing up in: their homes, schools, and communities.

It starts with listening. Really listening. To their frustrations, their fears, and even the silence between their words. Teens need to know they’re seen and valued for their achievements and who they are.

Moving Beyond the Blame Game

Blaming social media won’t solve the teen mental health crisis. Like any tool, its impact depends on how it’s used and the context in which it exists. The real solutions lie in parenting, educating, and creating spaces where teens feel safe, supported, and truly connected.

If you’re struggling to support your teen, or even yourself, you’re not alone. It’s okay to seek help. We can start asking the right questions and building the right solutions.

x